This is an installment of excellent fita column about exercise.
I had an eating disorder relapse in 2017. Nearing the end of my twenties, I regressed, spending time on pro-ana forums, crying in grocery store parking lots, and isolating myself from anyone who might tempt me to have a high-calorie good time.
My life was falling apart, but my ever-thinner body became a selling point at the studio where I taught Pilates. A potential client wanted to know if I got the shape I needed from Pilates, and I would say yes. small, small Details I thought Diet Coke was a meal.
Pilates, developed by Joseph Pilates, a stocky, barrel-chested man, is a low-impact training method that uses body weight and resistance to build both strength and flexibility. In Pilates, all movement comes from the core, which Pilates people often refer to as the “powerhouse.” Increasing core strength and flexibility is an antidote to many physical ailments in modern society. I like to call Pilates the best “anti-desk” exercise. Joseph Pilates wasn’t egotistical enough to give his training method his name. He called it “control.” But his goals were noble. In his 1945 book Bringing back life through control science, he described it as “a complete alignment of body, mind and spirit.” He wrote that the art of control “uniformly develops the body, corrects wrong postures, restores physical vitality, revitalizes the mind and uplifts the spirit.”
The name didn’t catch on, but the technique did. And Controlology’s modern rebranding included other changes. Marketing a somewhat esoteric training method developed by a long-deceased German man can be difficult, especially when most people go to the gym to lose weight. We, the fitness industry, and the Pilates community, subtly or not, promote Pilates as the ticket to a “longer, leaner” body. Gwyneth Paltrow practices Pilates! Kendall Jenner does Pilates! If celebrity endorsement doesn’t appeal to you, how about the idea of a “dancer’s body”? An article on a fitness website summarizes this relationship: “Pilates develops long, lean muscles in your arms, legs, and glutes. Doing Pilates regularly can help you get the shape and strength you’re looking for. It also improves your flexibility. This increases your ability to move smoothly, like a person dancing.”
Can you hear that? I’m the one screaming. I have been practicing Pilates for 12 years and as an instructor for about 7 years. At one point, what really made my body “long and toned” wasn’t doing Pilates. It was a combination of genetics and personality. very sick.
To explain in detail why the whole premise that “Pilates makes you look like a skinny ballerina” is bullshit, it starts with the phrase “toned muscles.” All muscles are lean tissue. Also, many Pilates instructors tell their clients to “stretch” to help visualize stretching, but this does not make the muscles longer. Also, there are many mistakes in the term “dancer’s body”. If we take this statement literally, the secret to a “dancer’s body” is starting dance training at an early age, rigorous dance training, and, sadly for many, diet. Many Pilates instructors look to you for this role because you’re a former or current dancer, not because you recently did 100 pull-ups in the Wonder Chair.
But if we look at the term critically, it goes back to George Balanchine, the American choreographer and ballet visionary who founded the New York City Ballet in 1948 and basically invented neoclassical ballet and the anorexic ballerina. i will be back. He had very particular ideas about what a ballerina should look like. Balanchine’s ideal dancer has a long graceful neck, long limbs, and as little body fat as possible. Looking at New York City Ballet dancer Gelsey Kirkland, Mr. Balanchine tapped him on the sternum and said, “You have to see the bones.” Balanchine’s body standards are still alive and well, with a New York City Ballet dancer claiming last fall that he had gained 10 pounds and was no longer able to perform roles.
Joseph Pilates was not a dancer. He was also a boxer and gymnast. But as his New York studio became a haven for dancers, his methods became associated with them. He developed a reputation for being able to “cure” dancers’ pain. By the 1960s, Pilates had become an accepted part of dancers’ training plans. Romana Kryzanowska, a student of Joseph Pilates, was a dancer, and much of the dance-like flourishes of Pilates exercises are Romantic.
I mean, a lot of dancers did Pilates, a lot of Pilates instructors were dancers, and the women who more or less codified classical Pilates were also dancers. There is a correlation here between the “dancer’s body” and Pilates, but correlation does not equal causation.
I’m not sure if I look like a “Pilates body” because of my body dysmorphia, but I haven’t cleansed in years and I no longer dread eating dinner. But since I’ve been eating more regularly and gaining weight, I’m sure I’ve gotten much better at Pilates.
When I was in group therapy for an eating disorder, another participant was also a Pilates instructor. We both vented about how teaching in front of the mirror all day and focusing on clients’ bodies made it difficult to recover. I hope she’s doing her best. I still hate mirrors, but it’s easier now.
I want to make it clear that I love Pilates. Practicing Pilates has improved my life in many ways. I’m strong, flexible, and have great posture. That’s what I want for my clients, and that’s what the Pilates body should look like..
Read more about Good Fit.
